This issue is across the board for moderator notification, reply to message notification, and private message notification.
If the person's E-mail address that is in their profile is hosted at our site (themomsconnection.com), they do not receive ANY E-mails at all (the accts work fine in regular test E-mails away from the boards).
In various tests that we ran, if the address was from anywhere BUT @themomsconnection.com, all notification worked perfectly.
We are running version 5.47e.
Just in case, the URL to our board is:
TMC Boards