Your memberslist.cgi may have been corrupted.
Grab the 5-series member rebuilder from this page, and run it:
https://www.ubbcentral.com/downloads/ That should help. You could also open up a support ticket.
(The rebuilder will ask that you turn your board off, which isn't really easy. You can edit the UltBB.setup file in Notepad - change the $BBStatus line from reading ON to OFF.)