I appreciate the help. I went to Styles>Name Images & Wrapper. Everything says default in there. I'm sure you're right. The only thing I kept was the database. All the html directory is completely clean.
I removed the extra melanie directory and reset all the paths. Same issue. I also went into the database tables. Poking around there didn't turn anything interesting up.
Might it be necessary to reset the styles completely? What would happen if I delete the ubbt_STYLES table?
Here is the current link:
http://arpeggioentertainment.com/forums/ubbthreads.php?ubb=cfrm
