Well, it's not repeating the original subject, it's repeating the subject they commented to; so say a user changes the topic and someone responds to that, it'd reference that topic...
Pretty annoying unless you're using threaded mode... A hybrid mode would make it a little more sane though...
As for getting rid of it, I think that if you go to scripts/newreply.inc.php find:
$Subject = "Re: ".$Subject;
Replace with:
// $Subject = "Re: ".$Subject;
On another note, i'm not sure why RE isn't in the language files...